From the arena
The lessons I got wrong
I've been teaching for over thirty years, and I've got plenty of it wrong along the way. These are the ones that actually changed how I coach.
I've been teaching riders for over thirty years. In that time I've got a great many things right, and I have also got things wrong, and the second list is the more interesting one.
I've thought about whether to write this. The obvious argument against is that nobody advertises their misjudgements. But I would rather you knew what I'm like, and what I'm like is somebody who will tell you when I have called something badly. A coach who's never got anything wrong in thirty years has either not been teaching very much or hasn't been looking closely.
So, four of them.
Pushing for a win that nobody asked for
Early on I believed that a lesson should finish on a high, and that a high meant achieving something.
So when a nervous rider was having a session that was going quietly well, I'd sometimes reach for one more thing. A short canter. A slightly bigger ask. The logic was that they'd go home with a win in their pocket and the confidence would compound.
Sometimes it did. But often enough what actually went home was the fright, not the achievement, and the next week we'd be starting further back than where we had finished.
What I got wrong was whose win it was. I wanted the session to have a shape. They wanted to feel safe, and they had already had the thing they came for about twenty minutes earlier.
Now, with a nervous rider, I stop asking for more the moment something has gone genuinely well, even if it's small. We still use the whole hour. We just spend the rest of it consolidating what worked, or on the ground, or talking through what to practise before I next see you. You get the full lesson either way. What you don't get is me chasing one more thing and handing back a horse, and a rider, who are both more wound up than when we started.
Mistaking quiet for agreement
I used to take a rider's silence at face value.
If I explained something and they nodded, I moved on. If they didn't raise a problem, I assumed there wasn't one. That seems reasonable, and for confident riders it usually is.
For everyone else it's badly wrong, and it took me longer than it should have to see it. People don't want to look difficult. They don't want to admit they're frightened of something that sounds small when you say it out loud. They don't want to be the client who complains. So they nod, and they get on, and they have a horrible time, and I don't find out for three weeks.
What changed is that I now ask directly and I ask in a way that makes the inconvenient answer easy. Not "are you happy with that?", which invites a yes, but "what part of that are you not sure about?", which assumes there's one.
The quiet ones are the ones to check on.
Reading the horse as the problem
This is the one I'd most want back.
For a stretch of my career I was quicker than I should have been to treat resistance as a training issue. A horse who wouldn't go forward, who was uneven, who was suddenly difficult about something he had been fine with. There's always a schooling explanation available, and if you go looking for one you'll find it.
A good number of times, over the years, the horse was telling us something and we were busy correcting the sentence.
I'm not a vet, and being clear about that is part of the point of this section. What I've learned isn't how to diagnose anything. It's to stop assuming, and to say out loud "this doesn't look like a training problem to me" much earlier than I once would have. That sentence costs a rider a phone call. Not saying it can cost a great deal more.
Sudden change is the flag. A horse who's always been sticky one way is a schooling conversation. A horse who was fine last month and isn't now is a different conversation, and it isn't mine to have.
Being right, and being no use
The last one is less dramatic and it's probably the most common.
There have been lessons where my technical analysis was correct, I explained it clearly, and the rider went home with nothing.
Usually because it was too much at once. Sometimes because it was the right correction for a rider two years further on than the one in front of me. And sometimes because I was interested in the problem, which is a genuine occupational hazard, and interest isn't the same as usefulness.
Being right about a horse is the easy part after thirty years. Working out which one true thing this person can take away and actually use this week is the harder skill, and it's the one I'm still working on.
Why I'm telling you this
Partly because it's true, and this site is meant to sound like me.
But mostly because it's the thing I'd want to know if I were choosing somebody to teach me. Not whether they've made mistakes, because they have. Whether they noticed, whether they changed, and whether they'd tell me.
If we work together and I get something wrong with you and your horse, you'll hear it from me. I would rather say it than have you quietly wonder.
Keep reading
- BlogArriving at a place I have never seenI've taught in a good many arenas across two countries, and every one of them was a space built for the job. Coming out to your place is the genuinely new part of this for me, and it has made me think properly about what I need to look at before we start.
- GuideGetting your confidence back in the saddleFor riders who've had a fall, a fright, or a long time away, and are quietly wondering whether they've left it too late.
- GuideHow to improve your riding, one percent at a timeWhy small, well-managed gains beat waiting for a breakthrough, and what one percent actually looks like in a lesson.
Coaching that comes to you
On your own horse, at your own place, across Townsville and surrounds.