From the arena
Your horse is not a bicycle
He has views, and some days they aren't your views. That isn't a fault in the machinery. It's the entire reason any of this is worth doing.
I say this in lessons more than almost anything else, usually to a rider who's frustrated, and usually about a horse who's just declined to do something he did perfectly well last Tuesday.
If you get on a bicycle and turn the handlebars, it turns. Every time, the same amount, regardless of how the bicycle is feeling about it, what happened to it yesterday, or whether it likes you. That's a machine, and a machine is a wonderful thing.
It's also not what you've got.
The thing riders are quietly hoping for
I think a lot of frustration in riding comes from a hope nobody says out loud: that with enough practice, the horse will become reliable in the way equipment is reliable. Press the button, get the answer. Same input, same output.
He'll get more consistent. A well-schooled horse who trusts his rider is a remarkably dependable animal. But he'll never be predictable in the way a machine is predictable, because he has a body that feels different on different days, a memory, a mood, and a set of opinions about wind, plastic bags and being asked to leave his friends.
Hoping otherwise sets you up to read every disagreement as a failure. Yours or his.
What the opinions are actually for
Here's the part worth sitting with. The opinions aren't the price of riding. They're the point of it.
If he had no view, there would be nothing to build. No trust to earn, because trust only means something from someone who could have declined. No partnership, because a partnership needs two parties. You'd be operating equipment, which is a perfectly good hobby, and you wouldn't need me.
Every rider I know who has stayed with horses for decades stayed for that. Not for the technical riding, though that's satisfying. For the fact that something large and quick and entirely capable of leaving decided, repeatedly, to go along with what you asked. That's worth something precisely because it was never guaranteed.
Which doesn't mean anything goes
I'm not making an argument for letting a horse do as he likes. That isn't kindness and it isn't safe.
Boundaries matter and horses are far happier with them than without. What I'm saying is narrower: when he disagrees, treat it as information rather than defiance. Something has changed, or he doesn't understand, or he's worried, or he hurts. Those have different answers, and none of the answers is "insist harder". See will not, or cannot? for the one that matters most.
The rider who says "he's being difficult" has usually stopped asking why. The rider who says "something is different today" is already halfway to sorting it.
The horses who taught me most
Not the easy ones. I've ridden some genuinely lovely, generous horses and I remember them fondly and learned very little from them.
I learned from the ones who wouldn't, and made me work out what I was actually asking. The ones who were fine for somebody else, which is a humbling thing to watch. The ones where the answer turned out to be nothing to do with training at all.
Every one of those cost me some pride and taught me something I still use. A bicycle has never done that for anybody.
So when he says no
Take a breath, and go through it in order.
Is he sore? Is the tack right? Did I ask clearly, or did I ask the way I ask when I'm tired and in a hurry? Is he actually able to do this today, in this ground, in this heat? Has something changed since the last time this went well?
Then, only then, is it a training question.
That order is the whole of what I'm trying to teach, and it's the difference between a rider who gets more out of a horse each year and one who slowly runs out of patience with an animal who was trying to tell them something.
Keep reading
- BlogWill not, or cannot?The most useful question you can ask about a difficult horse, and the one that decides whether you're looking at a training problem or a phone call to your vet.
- BlogForward is not the same as fastAsk most riders for more forward and you get more speed. They aren't the same thing, and nobody ever explains the difference.
- GuideLearning to read your horseHe's telling you something on every ride. Most of what looks like a training problem is a conversation you haven't learned to hear yet.
- GuideWhy lessons on your own horse are worth itWhat changes when you learn on the horse you actually ride, at the place you actually keep him.
Coaching that comes to you
On your own horse, at your own place, across Townsville and surrounds.