Horsemanship

Will not, or cannot?

The most useful question you can ask about a difficult horse, and the one that decides whether you're looking at a training problem or a phone call to your vet.

I want to be clear about where I stand before any of the rest of it. I'm a coach, not a vet. I can't tell you what's wrong with your horse and I'll never try. What I can do, after a long time watching horses go, is notice when something doesn't look like a schooling problem, and say so early enough to be useful.

That's the whole of this piece. One question, asked honestly.

The question

When a horse doesn't do what you've asked, there are two quite different explanations, and they look almost identical from the saddle.

He won't. He doesn't understand the question, or he's learned he can decline it, or he's worried about it. This is a training conversation, and it's mine.

He can't. Something hurts, or his body won't currently do what you're asking. This is a veterinary conversation, and it isn't mine.

Nearly every rider I meet has been taught to assume the first. It's the more comfortable assumption, because it comes with something to do about it. The second one is the more expensive thought, and it's the one people arrive at last rather than first.

The strongest signal is change

If you take one thing from this, take this.

A horse who's changed is telling you something. Not a horse who's always been sticky on the right rein, or who's never much liked poles. Those are old patterns and they're usually training or conformation. I mean the horse who was willing last month and is arguing this month. The horse who was forward and has gone flat. The horse who's always stood to be groomed and is now shifting and pinning his ears.

Consistent difficulty is a schooling question. Recent change is a health question until proven otherwise, and the sooner it's asked the better, because horses are extremely good at coping right up until they aren't.

Things worth taking seriously

None of these prove anything on their own. All of them are worth noticing, and worth mentioning to your vet if they persist or arrive suddenly.

  • Objecting to being saddled or girthed when he didn't used to
  • Ears back or tension the moment your weight lands in the saddle
  • A tail that clamps or swishes hard through work, rather than swinging
  • Going flat in a horse who's normally willing off the leg
  • Head tossing that appears with contact specifically
  • Stumbling, or a footfall that has stopped sounding regular
  • A canter lead he suddenly can't pick up, or bending that has got worse one way
  • Bucking, rearing or bolting that's out of character for him

That last one matters most and is the one most likely to be met with a firmer hand. A horse who's never done it and suddenly does isn't being naughty. He's saying something in the loudest way he has.

The rule I actually use

None of the above is answered with a stronger aid.

If the response to resistance is more leg, more rein, or a sharper correction, and the cause is pain, you've taught a horse in pain that telling you didn't work. Horses learn that lesson quickly and it's a genuinely hard one to undo. It also means the next signal is bigger, because the quiet one got him nowhere.

So when something changes, the answer is to get curious rather than firmer. Stop, have a look, and if it doesn't resolve, ring somebody who can actually examine him.

Two minutes before you get on

The most useful habit I can give you, and it costs almost nothing.

Before you tack up, run your hand firmly along his back on both sides and watch his reaction. Feel down his legs for heat or filling. Then walk him a few steps in hand and watch him move.

That's it. Do it every ride and you build a picture of what normal looks like for your horse, which is the only baseline that matters. Somebody who does this for a month will spot a change weeks before somebody who doesn't, and weeks is often the difference between a small problem and a long lay-up.

The same applies to his outline before you start. A horse who's tight through his back and neck before any work has begun is worth a second look.

What I do about it in a lesson

I'll tell you what I see, plainly, and I won't dress it up.

If something looks off to me we stop, or we change what we were going to do, and I'll say that I think it's worth a vet's opinion. I'd far rather be wrong about that in front of you than say nothing and be right. It's your horse and your money, and the decision is entirely yours, but you're entitled to my honest read of what I'm watching.

Sometimes it's nothing. Often enough it isn't, and the person who mentioned it first did the horse a real favour.

Frequently asked questions

How do I tell pain from bad behaviour? Ask what has changed and when. A long-standing difficulty is usually training. A recent change in a horse who was fine before is worth a veterinary opinion first. You aren't expected to diagnose it, only to notice it.

My horse is only difficult when I ride, not on the ground. Does that rule out pain? No, it makes it more interesting. A problem that appears only under saddle points at the saddle, your position, or something that only hurts under weight. All three are worth checking, and saddle fit is the one people leave longest.

Should I stop riding if I suspect something? Stop asking for whatever produces the reaction, and get advice before carrying on. You don't necessarily need to stop everything, but working through it is the one option I'd rule out.

He passed a vet check and is still doing it. Now what? Then it may well be training, and that's where I come in. It's also worth revisiting saddle fit and teeth if those weren't part of the check. A clear examination is useful information, not the end of the conversation.

Is this not just being over-cautious? Being wrong costs you a call-out fee. Not asking can cost a horse months. I know which way I would rather be wrong.

Coaching that comes to you

On your own horse, at your own place, across Townsville and surrounds.