From the arena
Patience, and where it goes
You can't hurry a horse into being ready, and trying to makes it take longer. Riders who spend years learning that tend to carry it out of the arena with them.
People say horses teach you patience. It gets said so often that it has stopped carrying much meaning, usually by people who've never owned one.
There's something real underneath it, though, and it isn't the version that goes on a tea towel. It's more specific and a good deal less comfortable, and it starts with a fact about horses that most riders spend their first few years arguing with.
The timeline belongs to the horse
You decide what you're working on. You don't decide when he's got it.
That isn't a nice way of putting something. It's a plain description of the job. You can set the exercise up properly, ask clearly, stay consistent, and give him every reasonable chance. What you can't do is bring the day forward by wanting it more than you did last week.
It's genuinely odd to watch, because progress doesn't turn up on the day you earned it. A horse who half understood something on Thursday is often noticeably better at it the following Tuesday, having done nothing in between but stand about in a paddock. Nobody taught him anything on the weekend. He simply had it, and then he had it properly.
The other half of this is the half riders resist hardest: hurrying isn't a neutral choice that either works or doesn't. It's actively expensive. When a rider decides the thing is going to happen today, the ask gets louder, the horse gets tense, and tension is the exact opposite of the loose, thinking state in which a horse learns anything. So you don't get it today, and because he's now had some practice at being anxious about it, quite often you don't get it next week either. The three weeks you were trying to save turn into six.
What it looks like when a rider runs out
I can usually see it before the rider can. It looks much the same on most people.
The reins get shorter. The hands come back and down without anyone deciding to do that. The leg gets louder and starts nagging, on and on, instead of ask, answer, leave him alone. The rider stops breathing out. Shoulders come up towards the ears. Somebody who's been chatting to me all lesson goes quiet, or starts narrating what the horse is doing wrong rather than riding him.
The clearest tell is repetition without change. Same exercise, same corner, same way, just more of it and faster. That's a rider trying harder at precisely the thing that isn't working, and that's what running out of patience actually looks like from the ground. It rarely looks like temper.
The horse tells you as well. His head comes up, the stride gets shorter and quicker without getting more forward, and he starts anticipating instead of waiting for the aid. Once he's guessing, the exercise is finished whether or not anybody has said so.
So I stop it. Not with a gentle suggestion that we might have a bit of a walk. I stop the exercise, and the pair of them go on a long rein until the horse's neck comes down and the rider's shoulders come back to where they live.
Then one of two things. Either we change the question to one he can definitely answer, so that he gets to be right about something and she gets to feel a horse go softly again, or I take today's problem off the table altogether and say so out loud. There's still half a lesson left and plenty to do with it. A session that finishes on something small and correct is worth more than one that finishes on twenty minutes of insisting, and I've written elsewhere about how small a real improvement is allowed to be.
Often I'll just name it: we're both trying harder and it isn't working. Riders are almost always relieved when somebody says that, because they knew.
Then we look at the question rather than the horse, because running out of patience is usually downstream of an ask that wasn't fair to start with. Three I put to the rider, in this order:
Are you asking the same way every time, or is it a little different each ride? Are you asking too early, before he's ready for that movement at all? And have you set him up to get it right, or set him up to fail and then been disappointed in him for failing?
It's the ask, not the tell. Which means listening to the horse rather than talking at him, and that's most of the job.
Waiting isn't doing nothing
I want to separate two things that get muddled, because patience has a soft reputation it doesn't deserve.
Being patient isn't lowering the standard, and it isn't letting the horse decide how the session goes. You still ask clearly and you still mean it. What changes is that you stop putting a deadline on the answer.
The practical version of this is the gap between the ask and the reply. Most riders ask, then ask again before the horse has finished working out what the first one meant, then a third time and louder. Three questions have now been asked, none of them has been answered, and the horse has learned that the first ask doesn't count. Sitting through that gap on purpose, while everything in you wants to repeat yourself, is one of the harder skills in riding. It looks like nothing is happening. A fair amount is.
There's a difference between waiting and drifting, mind. Waiting has an intention in it. You're still asking, still expecting, still going somewhere. You're simply not standing over him with a stopwatch.
Where it goes
Here's the part I'm more careful about, because I coach riding and I'm not qualified to make claims about anybody's character.
What I can tell you is what I see. A rider who's been at this a few years handles a session going sideways differently from one in their first season. Not because they're calmer by nature. Because they've had the experience, several hundred times over, of a thing not working on a day when nobody was at fault, and then coming good three weeks later anyway. That's an unusual education. Most of what fills a person's week gives them an answer straight away, or appears to. A horse won't, and can't be made to.
It doesn't seem to stay in the arena. Parents mention it to me more often than the riders do, and when they do they're usually talking about homework or exams rather than horses. Adults who ride tend to be harder to panic when something at work is plainly not going to be finished on the day it was promised. I can't prove the horse caused any of that. People who stay with horses for years may well have been that sort of person before they ever got on one. But I have watched it for long enough to think there's something in it, and it's the part of this job I'd keep if I had to give up the rest.
And the days it deserts you
None of this makes anybody serene, and I wouldn't want you thinking it made me serene either.
Patience isn't something you acquire and then own. It runs out. It runs out on a hot afternoon at the end of a long day, with a horse who's developed strong views about a shadow he's walked past a hundred times. That happens to everyone, including the person standing in the middle of the arena telling you about waiting.
What thirty-odd years of horses actually gives you isn't immunity. It's a much shorter gap between losing your patience and noticing that you have. Ten seconds instead of ten minutes. All of the useful behaviour lives in that gap, and unlike temperament it can be trained.
So if you're three weeks into the same exercise and quietly convinced you ought to be further along, I'd say what I say in the arena. You aren't behind. He was never on your schedule. He's on his, and he was never a bicycle that would run on yours.
Keep reading
- BlogYour horse is not a bicycleHe has views, and some days they aren't your views. That isn't a fault in the machinery. It's the entire reason any of this is worth doing.
- BlogWill not, or cannot?The most useful question you can ask about a difficult horse, and the one that decides whether you're looking at a training problem or a phone call to your vet.
- BlogThe lessons I got wrongI've been teaching for over thirty years, and I've got plenty of it wrong along the way. These are the ones that actually changed how I coach.
- GuideHow to improve your riding, one percent at a timeWhy small, well-managed gains beat waiting for a breakthrough, and what one percent actually looks like in a lesson.
- GuideGetting your confidence back in the saddleFor riders who've had a fall, a fright, or a long time away, and are quietly wondering whether they've left it too late.
Coaching that comes to you
On your own horse, at your own place, across Townsville and surrounds.